Pets advent calendars

BARK Howly Jowly Holidays Dog Toy & Treat Advent Calendar

Why it made the list: 8 full BARK plush toys and 16 treats in 8 flavors, so it's more than a box of biscuits.

What reviewers say about quality: Advent Center (4/5): "a dog calendar rather than a biscuit box with a bow on." Downside: the plush toys come in one size only.